Judging and perceiving (3-Deborah)

I’ve begun to see the book of Judges as a historical theology narrative in which Israel’s stark slide toward ignoring God’s kingship may be perceived.  Faith-wise, the Israelites definitely appear to have plunged in the time of the Judges.  (Find the first two posts in this series here.  I anticipate 3-4 more.)

Having skipped lightly over Shamgar, because the text nearly does the same, we see that Deborah, the 3rd judge, is unique:

  1. She is a prophetess.
  2. She is presented as having had a place for judging.
  3. It is not as a military leader that she earns her role.
  4. She is a woman.

Why, when I was a 9-year-old at Vacation Bible School, had my memorization list included Barak’s name along with Deborah’s as a Judge?  Barak seems to be a non-entity, really.)  In the story, Deborah’s prophecies and courage eclipse Barak’s might.  He is criticized for a lack of courage,.  The horrific story of the enemy Sisera’s death seems to show not only Jael’s (didja catch that name? Jah-El!  Yahweh is God!) fearlessness but also the courageous faith of Deborah.  It’s a victory, but not by traditional male might.  What’s highlighted here is the power of women who were willing to take action.

Then comes the notable “Song of Deborah and Barak,” as the heading sometimes goes.  It takes up an entire chapter of Judges, indicating its historical and theological significance within the narrative.  A general principle of narrative interpretation is that when a portion of the story is notably longer (a conversation, a description, or in this case, a song of victory), the reader should take notice.  And this song takes a whole chapter!

The song itself seems largely inaccessible to the modern ear.  This is no “Wichita Lineman” or “She Loves Me, Yeah, Yeah, Yeah.”  I suppose it’s more akin to “Battle Hymn of the Republic,” but that’s another story.  Some tribes or portions of tribes are taken to task for not heeding the battle call.  The exploits of other tribes are praised.  The song’s overall impact, I suppose, is clear, but along the way, it speaks things that do not resonate or even make sense to me.  The closing sentiment (5:28-30) about Sisera’s mother looking for her son, the now-dead general, to come home is just mean.  The song’s conclusion seems to be cognizant of the Lord’s role, and Israel, having apparently relied a little on God for a short time, “had rest for 40 years” . . . but then did what was evil.  Again.

And this time, at least in the narrative, God seems resistant to delivering them.

Next:  Strength and weakness . . . Midian and Gideon




One thought on “Judging and perceiving (3-Deborah)

  1. Steve Kell 08/27/2019 / 9:16 am

    One of my favorite verses in this section (NIV 1984) is: “When the princes of Israel take the lead, when the people willingly offer themselves, praise the LORD.” (5:2) I don’t think the order is coincidental.

    “The closing sentiment (5:28-30) about Sisera’s mother looking for her son, the now-dead general, to come home is just mean.” — well… war is mean. Note 4:3…not just oppression by the aforementioned general, but “cruel” oppression–and the poetic response balances such harshness. Also…it might be kept in mind that there is a post-script to his mom’s longing for his return (as is the heart of every mom of every soldier…): the Canaanite culture reflects the practices of the day–of plundering the rich spoils of the losers, of the abuse of the captured women, etc. (v30). Israel had divine boundaries when they defeated a foe; Canaanite greed and ruthlessness did not. (Thus–perhaps helping the modern reader understand in part in a broader picture the seriousness of Achan’s sin in that light–besides the Josh 6:17/18/21 understanding of the “giving over” gift to God.)

    Sisera’s demise event carried much weight in Israel’s military history, a rallying point when Israel faced overwhelming opposition-which they did regularly (and, by the way, still do, although it certainly is a “different Israel” today, not a theocratic society as in Biblical times). See Ps 83:9. “Remember the Alamo!” “D-Day!” “Midway” As you said, the song is significant!

    And..finally…yes, I learned the Judges using “the Judges song” too–and Barak gets unwarranted mention in the list!!

    Good thoughts–look forward to #4.

    Liked by 1 person

Please share your thoughts. I read every comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.