Bibliodoxy, conservatism, and liberalism

There is no clear, distinct definition of “conservative” or “liberal”;  these are always relative terms.  I think I can most often tell, after getting to know someone, whether he is more or less conservative than I.  Then again, humans have a penchant for inconsistencies, and I may be surprised by where someone falls in this or that discussion, on this or that question. . . .

Some folks in churches of my past (TX, AR, TN, DE, but maybe not CO) would’ve called me liberal.  Parodoxically, I think that would have been because those folks were not conservative enough.¹  Said another way:  compared to the “change agents” and “liberals” that some in those churches would vehemently lambaste, the latter were just liberal in a different way.   They were either not paying enough attention (harshly put), or paying a misguided kind of attention (more charitably, palatably put) to scripture.

Many leaders in my general tradition have been interested in restoring the “ancient order.”  This interest might be seen as patently conservative — even reactionary — and yet, when the restoratory methods are shallow, the end result is more liberal than the supposed restorers would ever want to admit.  In other words, what they end up restoring is further afield than they might realize from the ancient order.  In my book, this makes that kind of restorer liberal.  Certainly not radical, but not conservative, either.  It takes moorings to be conservative.³

Orthodox.  Now there’s a term.  I have very little interest in orthodoxy, though, so I don’t think I’ll take that one up, except to say that orthodoxy can end up liberal just as easily as it can end up conservative.

I can acknowledge the elusive nature of unity, no matter what we attempt to base it on, but if we were all more bibliodox, there would surely be more common ground.


¹ Others, perhaps including a few in our NY church, would call me uptight, and they’d be mostly right, but that’s beside the current point.²

² Does anyone ever read my footnotes?  I have fun composing them, but I guess I should know if no one bothers.  😀

³ If anyone clicked to this post to read about political, social, or even economic conservatism and liberalism, by now you’ve become fully disappointed.  Oh, okay . . . here’s a bit:  political liberals seem to me to have just about as many rational moorings as conservatives.  There.  That’s done.


4 thoughts on “Bibliodoxy, conservatism, and liberalism

  1. Lynn Rhodes 05/08/2012 / 5:45 pm

    In our Colorado days, my take is that on some issues you were more conservative than me and on others you were more liberal than me. Where did that leave us? Now my thinking has shifted on some points and I might agree with your more liberal views, but still not your more conservative views. So, where are we now? Hopefully, we can recognize that we are all supposed to be works in progress. If I keep spending time in the Word and keep learning more about God and my relationship to him, my liberal/conservative views will always be in a state of flux. I am not capable of arriving at or even understanding absolute truth. So I keep putting one foot in front of the other in my journey toward God.


    • Brian Casey 05/10/2012 / 9:52 am

      Thanks for the good thoughts. I have the feeling that we never really got to know each other during the short time of overlap in CO — mostly my fault, and the rest chalked up to situation (none of it your fault). I’m not sure what our differences might have been, but I imagine you’re right that they would be in different directions. And of course we *are* all works in progress, whether it’s progress in this direction or that. I hadn’t intended to imply otherwise … only meant to emphasize biblical moorings, but always recognizing that unity comes in diversity.


Please share your thoughts. I read every comment.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s